Alcohol Best Cure Hangover
Alcohol Best Cure Hangover
v • d • e This article is within the scope of WikiProject Food and drink , a collaborative effort to improve the coverage of food and drink related articles on Wikipedia. If you would like to participate, please visit the project page, where you can join the discussion and see a list of open tasks.
I think that last sentence is a run-on. If it's not, it's so long I can't tell for sure. Oi.
Interestly, the phrase, "or, more acurately, it's reverse" actually makes more sense to me than the edited version. The original concept is:
So, what the article is saying is that with homeopathic medicine & vaccines, the concept is reversed:
Of course, whether you believe that either vaccines or homeopathy work according to that concept is an indepedent discussion. 64.202.11.2 17:52, 30 September 2005 (UTC)
references needed
The assertion ""It is a shortened form of the phrase "The Hair of the Cocker Spaniel That Bit Your Hand"."" seems gratuitous. It reads to me as if someone were having a joke.
Two more detailed explanations: The first referrs to a poem credited to a Greek comic dramatist Aristophanes (448-387 BC): and -both seem to source the Dictionary of Phrase and Fable. The second is related to the translation of a Hebrew pun: .
Citations have been inserted into the article, but they do not link to any references. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 74.95.48.158 (talk) 04:41, 18 September 2008 (UTC)
Verifiability - No sources cited in article
This article seems to violate the Wikipedia verifiability rule. No sources are cited for alleged facts.
I found a source, and listed it. Someone may clean it up, if they want, but the phrase is listed in E. Cobham Brewer's Dictionary of Phrase and Fable (1898) (too old for general use?), attributed to a poem by Aristophanes. It's also in common use in TV and literature... I found some references in various TV show titles, "Gone with the Wind" (novel), and William Hazlitt's work.
False
Wow, I can't believe I'm doing this, but just in case anyone has left any doubt, or people couldn't interpret the nerd-speak, IT DOESN'T WORK. It has no scientific basis and has nothing to do with vaccines, because it doesn't involve viruses or bacteria. Any doctor will tell you it's hogwash (although he wouldn't the word 'hogwash') and as stated above, the best thing is not to over-indulge, but if you do... I recommend, eating a banana, taking a multi-vitamin and a couple aspirin BEFORE you start drinking. If you forget, then do it in the morning and drink lots of agua (something you should do while you're drinking also, they say one glass of water per drink is best). If you really overdo it and feel naseous, for God's sake, let it go and get that leftover alcohol out of your system asap (before you take your vitamins etc of course).
Don't Delete
While I agree that perhaps origins and accuracy of the phrase might need to be checked, the article should definitely stay. Of course this is not a "cure" for a hangover, everyone knows that, but people do it. Linking to the hangover article might be a good idea.
I agree about not deleting, but it has to be mentioned clearly that this practice is dubious.--Greece666 02:24, 18 May 2006 (UTC)
It may work
Alcolhol has traditionally been used as an anaesthetic. I presume due to it´s depressive effect on the brain, as described in the article. Of course, this can be used to lessen the pain, head-ache and maybe also psycholygical moodyness coused by hangover. It also makes it easier for the poor drunkard to fall asleep. The use may be unwise, but to explicitly state that the method doesn´n work is to go too far.
Commercial use of the phrase
I removed ""Hair O' The Dog" is a small chain of liquor and fine wine stores in Easton, MD, USA" from Notes. Other uses of the phrase, if they are notable and meet the other Wikipedia criteria should be placed in their own article and listed on the Hair of the dog (disambiguation) page. Bejnar 16:49, 1 August 2006 (UTC)
Treatment notice
The "Treatment notice" Medical professionals should be consulted about the proper treatment for hangovers, alcohol withdrawal, and withdrawal from other drugs. was placed in the article after several people complained that 'hair of the dog' treatments didn't work and that therefore the article ought to be deleted. They didn't seem to understand the difference between the facts about a cultural concept and the absolute truth of the concept. Notice restored as it keeps people from making foolish edits. Bejnar 22:59, 10 December 2006 (UTC)
Scientific Background
This sentence does not make scientific sense: "Medically, consuming alcohol may help with mitigating the headache of a hangover by depressing the central nervous system".
Alcohol depresses the CNS. The sentence does not explain why drinking more alcohol once hungover improves things with a the depression of the CNS?
Delirium Tremens is a syndrome due to alcohol withdrawal Not a symptom.
This sentence does not make scientific sense: "Some researchers have suggested that ethanol may help dilute other alcohols that cause many of the hangover symptoms, but no controlled studies have been carried out."
I would suggest a reference before considering it for inclusion.
"Depending on the amount of alcohol consumed, the type of alcohol, the amount of water consumed with the alcohol, the health of the consumer, and the accommodation to alcohol of the consumer, a hangover will last from a few hours to a few days." Deleted as this refers to Hangover. A little too much of this talk in the Scientific background of Hair of the dog.
Homeopathic
This page is about Hair of the Dog. The only mention of Homeopathic cures is to compare and contrast them. This is not the place to argue about how and whether homeopathic cures work. --Bejnar 00:14, 28 January 2007 (UTC)
- Regarding the production of similar symptoms. One does not have to believe in the efficaciousness of homeopathy, to realize that capsium, in volume, can produce watery eyes and nose. Allopathic medicine (non-deprecatory usage) may be using homeopathic methods to deal with allergies. They mix up these person specific shots containing pollen in order to develop resistance. See, for example "Allergy shots: Hope for long-term allergy relief" from the Mayo Clinic. Personally I don't believe in homeopathic medicine. I take decongestants and antihistamines. We need to avoid weasel words if possible. It is claimed is not necessary here, nor is the debate. If there is factual dispute about homeopathy, that should be dealt with in the Homeopathy article. --Bejnar 23:59, 29 January 2007 (UTC)
Popular culture and The Shining
Wy was my reference to The Shining removed?? I could agree about the werewolf part not being relevant, but why the whole reference itsef is less relevant than the others??? -- NIC1138 00:10, 16 March 2007 (UTC)
Origin and derivation
I believe that the editor who removed the text below was correct. It does not relate to the theory about consuming alcohol to cure a hangover. It is not sympathetic magic. --Bejnar 15:01, 3 June 2007 (UTC)
Popular culture references
Reverted the change to remove the pop culture references, seemed silly to remove them in the first place though I think it should be trimmed up a little bit.
In popular culture
The "in popular culture" was just a list of any time anyone ever heard the phase used, so i blanked it.160.36.238.124 (talk) 18:
Hangover Cure - Hangover Remedies
We have information on hangover cures and some of the best ways to cure ... Hangover Cure From A TO Z. A hangover is an after-effect of intoxication. Alcohol being a diuretic leads to ...
Hangover Cure - Hangover Drink - Best Hangover Cure ...
The best hangover cure drink on the market. Buy THC-The ... It is not meant to treat, prevent or cure any disease. The Hangover Cure does not prevent intoxication, alcohol ...
Best Hangover Prevention - Best Hangover Cure
The best hangover prevention is to drink clear alcohol. How to prevent a hangovers, how to cure them and what foods and drinks are best for curing hangovers.
Alcohol-X - Hangover Cures - Hangover Remedies - How To ...
“Because I hate the foggy feeling that comes with a hangover!” “I take Alcohol-X ...
Best Hangover Cure - Hangover Remedy - Hangover ...
Your best resource for hangover cures, remedies and prevention. Discover the best, easiest and most ... this will help process the remaining alcohol and cure your hangover. Step 1 ...
The Best Hangover Cures - Myths Or Genuine?
Obviously, the best idea of all is just not to drink any alcohol, but if that's not an option consider preventing the hangover with natural hangover prevention and cures.
What Exactly is a Hangover?
... of factors that play a role in why one person experiences a hangover after drinking alcohol and ... cuttieg1rl on What are people's best hangover cures? edk on What are people's best ...
Best Hangover Cure - Hangover Cure - Hangover Drink ...
Hangover Cure - Hangover Drink - Best Hangover Cure ... Common sense says that if alcohol causes dehydration then water is a great hangover cure drink.
Hangover Cures: Best Books To Ease In The New Year ...
Read More: Alcohol, Books, Drinking, Hangover Cures, Hangover Remedies, Hangovers, New Years, New ... Luckily, we've rounded up the best books to cure your hangover, including some ...
YouTube - Hangover Cure
The Best Hangover Cure In The World..!! ... Top Hangover Pills - Chaser or Alcohol-X
